IHP news #482 (August 10, 2018)
Highlights of the week
Planet at Risk of Heading Towards Apocalyptic, Irreversible ‘Hothouse Earth’ State
Scientists issued a new warning about climate change this week, as a major study reported its findings on the risk of earth entering a hothouse state. “Hothouse Earth”, an apocalyptic nightmare in which the global average temperature and sea levels would significantly higher than at any time in Earth’s recent history, would “cause serious disruptions to ecosystems, society, and economies” and make large parts of the Earth uninhabitable. The authors remind us of the need to “become responsible planetary stewards in the next ten years”, if we are to avoid finding ourselves at this point of no return.
Reproductive Rights in Latin America: A luta continua
Sad news from Argentina, where lawmakers have rejected a bill to legalize elective abortion in the first 14 weeks of pregnancy. The Catholic Church remains very powerful in Pope Francis’s homeland, but abortion rights activists remain hopeful that safe and legal access is just a matter of time: “We might not have a law today, but it is going to happen. Argentina is not going back to this, it is important for the women, especially for the young women.” Amnesty International estimates that more than 3,000 women have died in Argentina in the past 25 years as a result of an unsafe abortion.
Meanwhile in Brazil, the Supreme Court is in the midst of hearings that could result in the decriminalization of abortion in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. Feminist campaigner and anthropology professor Debora Diniz has been forced into hiding after receiving death threats.
Ebola Vaccinations Begin in North Kivu
The WHO announced on Wednesday that vaccinations have begun in the volatile North Kivu Province, site of the latest Ebola outbreak in the DRC. They are using an experimental vaccine that showed early successes during the recent outbreak in Equateur Province, but security concerns are complicating vaccination efforts.
Italy Backtracks on Mandatory Vaccination
Italy’s upper house has approved an amendment that removes mandatory vaccination for school children. Once it passes the lower house, it will suspend a child vaccination law that was introduced last year by the Democratic Party during an outbreak of measles. According to the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC), Italy accounted for 34% of all reported measles cases in the European Economic Area in 2017. The skepticism about vaccinations reflects broader a distrust of institutions.
Venezuelan problems for Columbia’s new president
Crisis in neighboring Venezuela poses a tough challenge for Ivan Duque, Colombia’s new President who took office this week. Thousands of refugees continue to cross the border each day, and while Colombia has been granting them residency and work papers, increasing numbers will certainly put pressure on the country’s already stretched resources.
NCD Alliance: UN Draft Political Declaration Lacks Required Strength and Ambition
In a media release put out on Wednesday, the NCD Alliance criticized the draft Political Declaration to be adopted at the third UN High-Level Meeting on Noncommunicable Diseases in New York on September 27th. The omission of a sugar tax was one of the highlighted weaknesses of the declaration.
Global governance of health
What Happened to PEPFAR’s $100M Key Population Investment Fund?
Deboah Birx, head of the US President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, says government bureaucracy prevented the announced direct funding of NGOs and in-country groups targeting key populations living with HIV, from taking place. The $100M Key Population Investment Fund will now be delivered through US government agencies instead.
UN Risks Falling Behind on Global Drug Policy
Governments are increasingly turning away from the supply-reduction approach that has long dominated but yielded little success in global drug control efforts. Paralyzed by conflicting demands of its member states, UN has been slower to react, hindered in part by its tradition of consensus decision-making and the powerful security cooperation dimension to the global war on drugs. The organization is at a pivotal crossroads, but next year’s sessional meeting of the Commission on Narcotic Drugs in Vienna, may be an opportunity to make a decision and take a firm stand, either way.
Human Resources for Health
Are Our ‘UHC Systems’ Learning Systems?
Akhnif et al.: https://health-policy-systems.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12961-018-0340-y
“If there is one universal recommendation to countries wanting to make progress towards Universal Health Coverage (UHC), it is to develop the learning capacities that will enable them to ‘find their own way’ – this is especially true for countries struggling with fragmented health financing systems. This paper explores results from a multi-country study whose main aim was to assess the extent to which UHC systems and processes at country level operate as ‘learning systems’.”
Polio in Papua New Guinea
A third polio victim has been confirmed in PNG, with the WHO reporting an additional 55 suspected cases. Surveillance has been stepped up, but the vaccination coverage being far below the required level in many provinces, they are fears that the virus could emerge in populations which were inadequately immunized.
Measles Outbreak in the Americas
A measles outbreak that originated in Venezuela is now spreading throughout the Americas, threatening unvaccinated local and indigenous populations.
The Cost of Public Health Decisions
Making the right public health promoting decision can often come at a substantial cost, as Transport for London found out this week. It has been estimated that a proposed ban on junk food advertising on public transport could wipe off a whopping £13M a year from TFL’s advertising revenue.
Other more less obvious costs can come in form of backlash to such proposals, especially when powerful commercial interests and industry lobbying are involved. Stephen Bendle suggests a few strategies for dealing with it.
Addressing the Venezuelan Migrant Crisis
With the situation in Venezuela getting worse and no resolution in sight, the international community must prepare itself for the possibility that migrants from the country will be displaced for a protracted period. This means that the response must go beyond meeting immediate humanitarian needs. Cindy Huang and Kate Gough from the Center for Global Development propose and outline several priorities which include regularizing Venezuelans’ legal status, forging a regional response, improving local service delivery, and stepping up US engagement in the region.
Report: The Linkages between Migration, Agriculture, Food Security and Rural Development
A joint FAO, IFAD, IMO, WFP report highlights the role of agriculture and rural development in addressing the drivers of migration, with food (in)security playing a central role.
Climate Change: The Biggest Health Problem in the World
“[Physicians] are the natural content experts in terms of framing in the most productive way the most important issue of our time—in the last remaining time window for productive action.” Courtney Howard, International Policy Coordinator for the 2018 Lancet Countdown on Health and Climate Change, on how and why she made the move from emergency doctor to climate change activist.
Report: Suva Expert Dialogue on Loss and Damage Associated with Climate Change Impacts
The UNFCCC Secretariat has published a report of the two-day expert dialogue which took place May 2-3 in Bonn, Germany. The meeting sought to enable open exchanges between technical and policy experts, and the co-creation of comprehensive risk-management solutions to extreme weather events and slow onset climatic processes.
Armyworm threatens food security in Asia
The arrival of the fall armyworm in the southern Indian state of Karnataka has put the whole country on alert. The caterpillar, an invasive species that is native to the Americas, has spread rapidly since its arrival in Nigeria in 2016, devastating crops and threatening food security across Africa.
Plus ca change…
Lant Pritchett on what he calls the new fad of randomized controlled trials in development, and the lessons from previous development process research that it seems to have ignored.
Cash transfers and labor supply: Evidence from a large-scale program in Iran
Salehi-Isfahani and Mostafavi-Dehzooie; https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0304387818306084?dgcid=rss_sd_all
In this paper which examined the impact of a national cash transfer program on labor supply in Iran, the authors found no evidence of a negative effect on hours worked or labor force participation. Instead, their findings suggest that such program may have a positive effect among women and self-employed men.
Japan Embraces the 100-Year Life
The Japanese translation of the 2016 book The 100-Year Life has proven to be a bestseller. The book, whose central theme is that “individuals, institutions, government, finances and infrastructure need urgent preparation for a time when millions can reasonably expect to live for a century”, seems to have resonated strongly with the Japanese people, probably because the country is home to the world’s oldest population. Now the search is on for fitting policy reforms.
It has emerged that Oxfam did not ban staff from paying for sex until last year, reportedly because of concerns over its staff’s personal rights and sexual needs. Other major NGOs banned the practice earlier, following a 2003 UN guidance.
Meanwhile in the UK, experts warn that sexual abuse by aid contractors may be going under the radar. They are calling for private firms delivering aid programs to have the same level of DfID scrutiny and reporting requirements as charitable organizations.
Diversity in Humanitarian Leadership
The Humanitarian Advisory Group, with support from the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, is spending the next two years trying to answer questions like: “is a lack of diversity at the leadership level stymying the humanitarian sector’s ability to address sexual harassment and exploitation?” The first paper in the research series was published last week.
Data Consent in Humanitarian Contexts
Data protection and (affirmative) consent have become a basic requirement for data collection in much of the global North, but what role can and does such data consent play when dealing with vulnerable populations in humanitarian contexts? Concerns arise not only around the collection, but also the storage and protection of deeply personal but increasingly lucrative health data.
EU Considering Cash Transfer Choices
ECHO, the EU’s humanitarian arm, is running a market assessment to determine whether a controversial new approach to coordinating humanitarian cash transfers would work in practice.
China to Surpass Australia as Biggest Pacific Aid Donor
Beijing’s pledge of US$4bn in aid to the Asia Pacific region, last year, has seen the country overtake Australia, traditionally the largest donor in the region, which pledged just a quarter of that. There is unease around the news in Canberra which is suspicious of China’s motives.
The securitization of Foreign Aid
20 years after the US embassy bombings in Nairobi and Dar es Salaam, Michael Igoe reflects on the rise of “countering violent extremism” as a US global development priority.
Civil Society Organizations Question the Veracity of Self-Reported SDG Status Updates
Unhappy with flexible and often cherrypicked government Voluntary National Reports, various civil society actors have begun developing shadow reports on SDG progress, paying specific attention to the often overlooked cross-cutting principle of “leaving no one behind.”